Health System Assessment Released at Critical Time for Guatemala
The results of Guatemala’s new Health System Assessment (HSA) were recently released in Guatemala City to a wide audience, including Vice President Jafeth Cabrera, Minister of Health Dr. Alfonso Cabrera, and United States Ambassador Todd Robinson.
The report provides the Government and the international community with a baseline diagnosis of the current health system. It also presents seven cross-cutting recommendations for strengthening the health system as well as specific recommendations for each health system building block. The HSA is available on the HFG website in English and Spanish.
Local stakeholders emphasized that the HSA report was presented at a critical time. The new presidential administration is seeking to address the ongoing health care crisis in the country, which has included frequent stock-outs of medicines as well as closures at the national referral hospital. The Health Finance and Governance project provided technical assistance in conducting the HSA.
The report’s release was covered extensively by the national media, including television. In a news segment, Carlos Avila, senior health economist with Abt Associates, explained the results: “First, the health system is underfinanced, it is necessary to invest resources for health. Second, the health system is fragmented; there is little coordination between the different institutions. And the third issue is about inequality: the inequality you can find between indigenous communities and Guatemala City, which concentrates most of the health resources, is very large.”
The findings and recommendations will help to inform policy dialogue on how to strengthen the system and expand access to health services, especially for vulnerable groups. The assessment found that the health system is severely under-financed and primarily financed by out-of-pocket expenditures, which is an inefficient and regressive form of financing healthcare, placing a large burden on poorer households. Other important findings included:
- Many Guatemalans in rural and predominantly indigenous communities lack of access to basic primary health care facilities – a situation that was exacerbated by the cancellation of the Programa de Extensión de Cobertura (PEC).
- The unequal distribution of health workers between urban areas (26 per 10,000) and rural areas (3 per 10,000) is a major barrier to improving primary health care in rural areas.
- The health system is highly fragmented, with little coordination between the Ministry of Health and the Social Security Institute, and often between different actors within each institution. Information systems are highly fragmented, for example, limiting policymakers’ ability to make evidence-based decisions.
HFG co-hosted the event with USAID’s Strengthening Health Outcomes through the Private Sector (SHOPS) project. The presentation of findings and recommendations is available in Spanish.